The Case Against Hiring Like-Minded People

Do you trust your gut instinct when it comes to hiring? If you do, you could be giving the job to the person you like best, not necessarily the best person for the job. There is a difference.

All of us carry unconscious biases that influence our perceptions and skew the weight we put on particular traits.  It is normal, and unintentional, but being aware of it during the recruitment process can ensure you bring a broad set of minds into the workplace.

Shannon Roberts is the Director of Talent Management for NZ and Queensland for global recruitment and talent management company, Hudson.  She says research shows diversity is good for the bottom line.

“Different personalities bring different skills and perspectives which is a key advantage in innovation,” says Roberts. “You are more likely to keep up with the pace of your competitors.”

Beaumont Consulting’s Managing Director Nina Mapson Bone says it’s natural to be drawn to someone similar to yourself, because we all think we are good at our jobs.

But the danger in a group mentality is it can limit opportunities and restrict financial growth.

“It’s easy to continue down a path without considering all the risks, all the opportunities or all the solutions,” she says. “If you have a diverse group of people that respectfully push agendas you will come out with more robust decision making, appeal to a broader range of customers and perform better over time.”

The AFL experience

In 2005 the Australian Football League made the decision to appoint a woman to its traditionally all-male commission. They headhunted Sam Mostyn for the role.

Mostyn says the foresight of former AFL chairman Ron Evans to bring in a woman’s perspective had secured the long-term future of the game. Until then the AFL was only represented one half of its supporter base.

It led to the establishment of the AFL Women’s league, which kicked off in February this year to a capacity crowd of 24,000 in the stadium and almost 900,000 TV viewers for the history-making match between Carlton and Collingwood.

“We now have a pathway for any girl or woman to pursue their desire to be an athlete in the game,” says Mostyn. “If we keep her in the game, her family and friends her will stay to support her and, when she has her own children, she won’t just be there as a supporter she will be an active participant.”

The ability to see the sport in a new light gave the AFL a product to maintain momentum in the off-season and also brought in new sponsorship opportunities at a time when television advertising was waning.

Mostyn, who is now deputy chair of the Diversity Council Australia, says the benefits delivered by a strong, diverse AFL board are the same at a company level.  “What you see is better conversations and a more complete picture.”

Tips for managing unconscious bias:

1. Find the meaning of success

Technical skills are important, but in many cases these can be developed. What often lets people down, says Mapson Bone, are personality traits.  She recommends seeing the job profile as a ‘success profile’ – what does the candidate need in order to excel in that role.

“People make the mistake of thinking Barry has left, we need another Barry, or they just hire according to Barry’s job description,” she says.  “This is the time to think, is this role critical, or is it an opportunity to take a fresh look at its function? Are there people in the organisation who need development or growth that could take on some of the role?”

Carefully defining the specific criteria needed can keep you focused on what matters.

2. Slow down

Unconscious bias is more likely to influence us when we are under time constraints or stressed, says Roberts.  Slowing down the recruitment process and putting science into the decision-making, she says, is a more reliable method of creating a diverse workplace than going with your gut, which is subjective.

Some companies use a ‘blind recruitment’ culling process where identifying criteria such as name, gender, age and place of residence are blocked out of resumes. Others use psychometric testing to identify unconscious biases or personality testing to determine the right fit for the team.

When it comes to shortlisting, a diverse talent pool ensures differences don’t stand out. A diverse panel also helps to negate bias with different interpretations of verbal and non-verbal cues.

3. Test for behaviours

Ask open-ended questions linked to the behavioural competencies the role requires.  If they will have difficult clients to deal with, test them for resilience. If they need to problem solve, find out how quick they are at it. Ask every candidate the same questions.

Mapson Bone recalls being eager to bring in someone she had previously worked with because she was a great person and great at her job but the panel gave it to someone else. They made the right choice.  “In hindsight there were two headstrong people in the team she had to work with and she was able to handle them really well, whereas the person I wanted probably would have struggled,” she says.

But while aiming for diversity is important, Roberts says it can’t be the only criteria.  “It’s still possible – and important – to have a good cultural fit where a person’s values, behaviours and motivations align with those of the organisation.”

Source: Parkes, B. (2017). The Case Against Hiring Like-Minded People. Retrieved April 28, 2017 from http://insightsresources.seek.com.au/case-hiring-like-minded-people